Skip to content

Cutting Board

Cutting board is one of the kitchenwares that comes most with our food. So I want it to be healthy, maintainable and good for my knives.
This research will explore the best cutting board materials for health, durability, and knife care.

Defining My Needs & Priorities

Before diving in, it's critical to define exactly what I'm looking for in a cutting board.

  • Primary Use Case(s): Daily food preparation, which consists of chopping vegetables and raw meat (requiring careful sanitization).
  • Key Features Needed:
    • Health & Sanitization:
      • Non toxic materials, that do not shed microplastics or leach harmful chemicals.
      • Should not harbor bacteria, or if it does, it should be easy to clean thoroughly and sanitize to prevent cross-contamination.
    • Knife-Friendly: The surface must be soft enough that it doesn't dull my knives prematurely.
    • Durability: Should resist deep scratching, warping, and splitting.
  • Budget Range: Flexible for a high-quality, long-lasting board
  • Deal-breakers (Things I want to avoid): Materials known to dull knives quickly (glass, stone), and toxic materials.

Researching the Field

Here are the main concepts, terms, and background information to understand before making a decision.

  • End-Grain vs. Edge-Grain (Wood):
    • Edge-Grain: Made by laminating strips of wood with the grain running horizontally. Less expensive, very durable, but shows knife marks more and is slightly harder on knives than end-grain.
    • End-Grain: Made by fusing short, vertical blocks of wood together. The knife edge slides between the wood fibers, making it "self-healing" and extremely gentle on knives. More expensive and requires more maintenance (oiling) to prevent drying out.
  • Janka Hardness Scale: A scale that measures the hardness of wood. For cutting boards, a "sweet spot" exists—too soft and the board scars easily; too hard and it dulls knives. Maple, Walnut, and Cherry are often considered ideal.
  • Microplastics: The shedding of tiny plastic particles from plastic cutting boards due to the cutting action of a knife.
  • NSF Certification (National Sanitation Foundation): A certification indicating that a product is tested and approved for use in professional food service environments, meeting certain standards for cleanability and safety.

  • Cross-Contamination: The transfer of harmful bacteria from one food item (like raw chicken) to another (like fresh vegetables) via a non-sanitized surface like a cutting board.

  • Keywords: best cutting board material, wood vs plastic cutting board, end grain vs edge grain, knife friendly cutting board, how to sanitize wood cutting board for meat, NSF certified cutting board.

Part 1: Choosing the Right Type of Cutting Board

First, I need to decide on the best type (material) of cutting board for my needs. The central challenge is safely handling raw meat without resorting to plastic. This leads to a two-board system as the only viable solution. The question is, what material should the second board be?

Available Types

1. Wood (e.g., Maple, Walnut, Cherry)

  • Overview & Key Selling Points: The traditional and often preferred choice. Wood boards are gentle on knives, durable, and naturally antimicrobial when properly cared for.
  • How it works with my Aspects:
    • Health & Safety Profile: Wood is the top contender for health. It does not shed microplastics. Hardwoods like maple are shown to have natural antimicrobial properties where bacteria are pulled into the wood fibers and die as the board dries. A wood board can be used for meat, but it requires a strict, non-negotiable cleaning protocol immediately after use.
  • Pros:
    • Best for knife longevity.
    • Naturally antimicrobial when properly maintained.
    • Durable and can last for decades.
  • Cons:
    • Requires regular maintenance (oiling).
    • Hand-wash only; cannot be sanitized in a dishwasher.
    • Using for meat requires a very disciplined cleaning regimen.

2. Composite (e.g., Richlite, Epicurean)

  • Overview & Key Selling Points: Made from wood fibers and food-safe resin, compressed under heat and pressure. They aim to combine the low maintenance of plastic with some durability of wood.
  • How it works with my Aspects:
    • Health & Safety Profile: Composite boards are non-porous and do not harbor bacteria. They are certified food-safe. However, they are still a synthetic product containing resins, which may not align with the goal of using the most natural materials possible. They are, however, dishwasher safe, which is a major advantage for sanitization after contact with raw meat.
  • Pros:
    • Dishwasher safe and easy to clean.
    • Very durable and low maintenance.
  • Cons:
    • Known to be very hard on knives, which conflicts with a key priority.
    • Made with resins, a synthetic material.
    • Can be slippery.

3. Plastic (e.g., HDPE, Polypropylene)

  • Overview & Key Selling Points: Utilitarian, cheap, and dishwasher safe.
  • How it works with my Aspects:
    • Health & Safety Profile: Rejected. While dishwasher-safe, plastic boards are known to shed microplastics directly into food. The inevitable knife grooves can also harbor bacteria, defeating the purpose of easy cleaning over time. This material is a deal-breaker.
  • Pros:
    • Dishwasher safe.
  • Cons:
    • Sheds microplastics.
    • Harbors bacteria in knife grooves.
    • Conflicts with the primary goal of a non-toxic kitchen.

Comparative Summary of Types

Aspect / Type Wood (for Meat) Composite (for Meat) Plastic (for Meat)
Health Excellent (natural, antimicrobial) Good (non-porous, but w/ resins) Poor (microplastics)
Knife Care Excellent Poor (very hard on knives) Fair to Poor
Cleaning High-Discipline (Hand-wash & Sanitize) Easy (Dishwasher Safe) Easy (Dishwasher Safe)
Maintenance High (requires oiling) Very Low Low (disposable)

Conclusion on Item Type

Given my non-negotiable requirement for a non-toxic and knife-friendly board, plastic is eliminated. The choice is between a strict two-wood-board system or a wood-composite system.

The composite board's primary advantage (dishwasher sanitization) comes at the cost of being harsh on knives—a major drawback.

Therefore, the best approach is a Two-Wood-Board System. This commits to using natural, healthy, knife-friendly materials for all food prep, accepting that this requires a higher level of user discipline.

  1. Primary Board: A large, high-quality wood board (preferably end-grain) for all non-meat tasks (vegetables, fruits, bread).
  2. Secondary Board: A second, dedicated wood board for raw meat, poultry, and fish. This board can be smaller and should be clearly identifiable. It must be cleaned and sanitized immediately after every use without fail.

This system fully aligns with my priorities of health and knife care.

Part 2: Choosing the Specific Cutting Boards to Buy

Now that I've decided on the two-wood-board system, I'll compare specific products for each role, focusing on high-quality but budget-friendly options suitable for home use.

Product Options: Primary (General-Purpose) Wood Board

This is the main workhorse board. The goal is the best possible quality and knife care for under $200.

1. Jones Cutting Boards Maple End-Grain Board (20"x14")

The Jones Cutting Boards Maple End-Grain Board

  • Overview & Key Selling Points: Consistently rated as the top pick by The Wirecutter, this board offers premium, end-grain construction at a reasonable price point. It's handcrafted in the US from domestic maple, making it an ideal choice for a primary board that is gentle on knives and built to last.
  • Pros (based on research):
    • Excellent Value: Offers the benefits of end-grain (knife-friendly, self-healing) at a much lower price than other high-end brands.
    • High-Quality Construction: Finely sanded with tight joints and arrives well-oiled.
    • Customizable: Can be ordered with feet (recommended for stability and preventing warpage) and a juice groove.
  • Cons (based on research):
    • Still a significant investment compared to mass-market boards.
    • Requires regular oiling and maintenance.
  • Price Range: ~$175
  • Community Says: Praised in online forums as a fantastic balance of quality and price, often recommended as the "sweet spot" for a serious home cook's first high-quality board.
  • How it Measures Up (against my needs):
    • Meets Need 1 (Health & Sanitization): Yes. Natural, antimicrobial wood.
    • Meets Need 2 (Knife-Friendly): Yes. The best possible construction for knife care.

2. Made In Butcher Block Cutting Board (18"x12")

The Made In Butcher Block Cutting Board

  • Overview & Key Selling Points: An excellent edge-grain maple board from a reputable direct-to-consumer brand. It's a great alternative if you prefer the look of edge-grain or if the Jones board is unavailable. It's known for being durable and gentle on knives.
  • Pros (based on research):
    • Very gentle on knives for an edge-grain board.
    • Solid, hefty construction feels stable on the counter.
    • Good size for most kitchen tasks without being overly cumbersome.
  • Cons (based on research):
    • Edge-grain will show knife marks more readily than end-grain.
  • Price Range: ~$129
  • Community Says: Well-regarded for its quality and value, a popular choice among home cooks who follow the brand.
  • How it Measures Up (against my needs):
    • Meets Need 1 (Health & Sanitization): Yes. Natural, antimicrobial wood.
    • Meets Need 2 (Knife-Friendly): Very Good. One of the better edge-grain options.

Product Options: Secondary (Raw Meat) Wood Board

This board should be smaller, affordable, and visually distinct from the primary board.

1. Ironwood Gourmet End-Grain Acacia Wood Cutting Board (14"x14")

The Ironwood Gourmet Acacia Board

  • Overview & Key Selling Points: Recommended as the best budget wood board by both The Wirecutter and Serious Eats. This acacia board provides an end-grain cutting surface at a very low price, making it a perfect candidate for a dedicated, high-risk meat board where you might be less concerned about long-term aesthetics.
  • Pros (based on research):
    • Exceptional Value: End-grain performance for a fraction of the price of maple or walnut.
    • Good Size for a Dedicated Board: The 14"x14" size is large enough for breaking down chicken or trimming steaks without taking up excessive space.
    • Dark Color: The dark acacia wood naturally hides stains well.
  • Cons (based on research):
    • Acacia wood is harder than maple and can be tougher on knives.
    • Craftsmanship is not as refined as more expensive boards.
  • Price Range: ~$50 - $80
  • Community Says: Acknowledged as a great value. Many users buy it specifically as a secondary board or for serving because of its looks and low price.
  • How it Measures Up (against my needs):
    • Meets Need 1 (Health & Sanitization): Yes. When following the strict sanitizing protocol.
    • Meets Need 2 (Knife-Friendly): Good. It's end-grain, but the harder wood makes it less gentle than maple.

Comparative Summary of Products

Feature/Aspect Jones (Maple End-Grain) Made In (Maple Edge-Grain) Ironwood (Acacia End-Grain)
Role Primary (General Use) Primary (General Use) Secondary (Raw Meat)
Price ~$175 ~$129 ~$65
Knife Care Excellent (Best) Very Good Good
Key Pro Pro-grade at a fair price Great value, solid brand Unbeatable price for end-grain
Key Con Still an investment Shows marks more easily Harder on knives

Conclusion on Specific Product

My choice is the Two-Board System with these budget-friendly picks:

  1. Primary Board: Jones Cutting Boards Maple End-Grain Board. This offers the best performance and knife care possible within the sub-$200 budget. It is a fantastic long-term investment.
  2. Secondary (Meat) Board: Ironwood Gourmet End-Grain Acacia Board. Its low price, appropriate size, and end-grain construction make it the perfect dedicated board for handling raw meat without fear of ruining an expensive primary board.

This combination provides the ideal balance of performance, safety, and value.

part 3: how to take care of it

Proper care is essential for wood cutting boards to ensure they are hygienic and last a lifetime. This is especially critical for the board designated for raw meat.

1. Daily Cleaning (After Every Use)

This applies to both boards immediately after you're done cutting.

  1. Scrape & Wash: Scrape off any loose food. Wash the board with a soft sponge, hot water, and a small amount of mild dish soap.
  2. Rinse: Rinse thoroughly with hot water.
  3. Dry Immediately: This is the most important step. Use a clean towel to dry all surfaces of the board completely.
  4. Air Dry Fully: Stand the board on its edge or on a drying rack to allow air to circulate around all sides, ensuring it dries out completely. Never lay a wet board flat on the counter.

2. Sanitizing (For the Raw Meat Board)

This must be done immediately after the daily cleaning step whenever the board has been in contact with raw meat, poultry, or fish.

  1. Prepare Solution: After washing and rinsing, prepare a sanitizing solution. The safest and most effective method recommended by food safety agencies is to use a solution of 1 tablespoon of unscented liquid chlorine bleach per 1 gallon of water.
  2. Apply Solution: Flood the surface of the cutting board with the bleach solution and allow it to stand for several minutes.
  3. Rinse Thoroughly: Rinse the board with clean water.
  4. Dry Immediately & Air Dry: Just as with daily cleaning, towel dry the board immediately and then stand it on its edge to air dry completely.

3. Monthly Maintenance (Oiling)

Once a month, or whenever the board looks dry or faded, it needs to be oiled. This prevents the wood from drying out, cracking, and warping.

  1. Ensure the Board is Clean & Dry: Start with a completely clean and dry board.
  2. Apply Oil: Use a food-grade mineral oil. Do not use cooking oils like olive or vegetable oil, as they can go rancid. Apply a generous amount of oil to the surface.
  3. Spread Evenly: Using a clean cloth, rub the oil into all surfaces of the board—top, bottom, and sides.
  4. Let it Soak: Let the board stand on its edge for several hours, or preferably overnight, to allow the oil to fully penetrate the wood fibers.
  5. Remove Excess: After soaking, use a clean cloth to wipe off any excess oil.

By following this routine, your wood cutting boards will remain safe, hygienic, and in excellent condition for years to come.

Sources & Further Reading

A list of resources I consulted during this research, categorized to ensure a well-rounded perspective. Numbers in brackets (e.g., [1]) in the text can refer to these sources.

Reputable Organizations & Consumer Information

  1. The Best Cutting Boards - The New York Times (Wirecutter)
  2. The Best Wooden Cutting Boards - Serious Eats
  3. Cutting Board Safety - Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics

Community Discussions (for anecdotal experiences & product discovery - cross-reference with scientific sources)

  1. Wooden cutting boards, which of these is the best? - Reddit (r/Cooking)

Product Pages (where to buy from, like manufacturer)

  1. Jones Cutting Boards

Join the Conversation

This is an ongoing process for me, and I'd love your input:

  • Do you use a two-board system in your kitchen? What materials have you chosen?
  • What is your cleaning and sanitizing routine for wood cutting boards, especially after preparing raw meat?
  • Are there other "buy it for life" quality wood board makers I should consider?

Disclaimer: This is a log of my personal research and decision-making process. Product features and prices are subject to change. Opinions are my own based on the information available at the time of writing.